Steve Jobs announced that the iPhone 3G would be "Twice as fast. Half the price".

Ever since Om Malik's interview with AT&T's Ralph de la Vega, people have been noticing and commenting on the fact that this ignores the mandatory 2-year AT&T contract, and in fact iPhone 3Gs will generally cost more, thanks to the higher monthly fees.

Unfortunately, Amy doesn't want my original $400 iPhone -- perhaps a friend who can't justify the 3G charges will buy it for $100.

The $300 16gb iPhone 3G will be worth the money for me -- I spend a significant amount of time each day waiting for pages to load, and still take a Treo 650 & Bluetooth GPS unit on driving trips. But I'm disappointed in Apple for choosing a clearly misleading catchphrase for a product which doesn't need deceit and customer confusion to sell well.

I don't use SMS much, but I do sometimes, and I don't want to worry about the astronomical per-message costs, so I like the $5/month flat rate plan. And I certainly want the $30/month unlimited 3G data plan.

Fortunately, I'm now able to drop back from the 900-minute/month plan I upgraded to, down to the base 450-minute/month plan, which will save $20/month, and nicely offset the additional $15/month for unlimited 3G & 200 SMS.

Now that AppleCare has failed me, and the iPhone isn't as much of a hardware investment, and I don't walk outdoors across campus (drops on carpet are much less destructive than on asphalt or concrete outside), I've decided not to purchase AppleCare or a case for my new iPhone (my 11-month-old plastic incase protector is falling apart, and kept the iPhone from fitting in any dock). I like the idea of leaving the iPhone charging in its dock overnight, rather than lying on a night table.

So with the new iPhone, I'll save $70 on a 2-year AppleCare contract and $30 for the case. This is enough to pay for MobileMe service. Hopefully it will be solid, as opposed to the current .Mac service, based on the unreliable iSync.

I wonder how much turn-by-turn GPS with spoken directions will cost on the iPhone. I know TomTom and Garmin are quite interested, and Google Maps can do real-time driving GPS without spoken directions -- I don't know what the iPhone options will be, though.

I have a couple large questions. First, how well will MobileMe work? Second, how much will turn-by-turn GPS with spoken directions cost? Hardware GPS units are in the several-hundred-dollar range, while Google offers free or cheap GPS with directions but no speech. I'm looking forward to seeing what is available using the iPhone SDK.

I'll have a much faster iPhone (and probably OpenSSH -- hooray!), and next time an attractive upgrade rolls around, I won't have $500 invested in the previous generation.


To sum up, I'll save $20/m on extra minutes, and pay an additional $15/m on 3G data & SMS. I'll save $100 on protection, and pay $100/year on MobileMe. If things don't change over the next 2 years, I'll end up paying $40 more, which isn't bad, but also isn't "Half the price."